Bitcoin ETFs: Definition, Pros and Cons, and How it Compares to Holding Bitcoin Directly

If you're interested in breaking into finance, check out our Private Equity Course and Hedge Fund Course, which help thousands of candidates land top jobs every year.

Start Preparing

What is a Bitcoin ETF?

A Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is a financial product designed to track the value of Bitcoin, providing investors with exposure to the cryptocurrency without needing to own or store Bitcoin directly. 

This investment vehicle allows both retail and institutional investors to participate in the Bitcoin market by buying shares of the ETF through traditional stock exchanges. Bitcoin ETFs aim to combine the volatility and potential upside of Bitcoin with the ease of access, liquidity, and regulatory oversight of the traditional financial markets.

Bitcoin ETFs offer a simpler way to invest in Bitcoin, especially for those who are unfamiliar with managing digital wallets and private keys. Additionally, investors benefit from trading on exchanges governed by regulatory bodies, providing more security compared to some cryptocurrency exchanges.

How Bitcoin ETFs Work

Bitcoin ETFs operate similarly to other ETFs that track assets such as gold, oil, or equity indexes. When investors buy shares of a Bitcoin ETF, they are purchasing exposure to Bitcoin’s performance through a regulated product.

1. Fund Managers: Bitcoin ETF managers either hold physical Bitcoin in custody or invest in Bitcoin futures contracts, depending on the type of ETF.

2. Shares Listed on Stock Exchanges: Shares of the ETF are traded on regulated markets such as the New York Stock Exchange or the Toronto Stock Exchange. Investors can buy and sell these shares throughout the day, just like stocks.

3. Tracking Bitcoin’s Performance: The value of the ETF fluctuates in line with Bitcoin’s price, reflecting any gains or losses.

4. Dividends and Reinvestment: While not common, some ETFs may reinvest profits to maximize returns for investors.
   

Types of Bitcoin ETFs

1. Spot Bitcoin ETFs

Spot Bitcoin ETFs hold Bitcoin directly. The ETF’s value closely follows Bitcoin’s real-time (spot) price on the open market. Investors gain exposure to Bitcoin's price movements without the complexities of purchasing or storing the digital asset.

Spot ETFs tend to be more attractive to investors because they offer direct exposure to Bitcoin’s current price, reducing the tracking discrepancies that futures-based ETFs may experience.

2. Bitcoin Futures ETFs

Futures-based ETFs invest in Bitcoin futures contracts instead of the underlying asset. Futures contracts are agreements to buy or sell Bitcoin at a predetermined price on a future date. These ETFs do not hold Bitcoin directly, meaning their performance may slightly differ from Bitcoin’s spot price, especially during volatile market conditions.

Bitcoin futures ETFs are exposed to contango (when future prices are higher than spot prices) or backwardation (when future prices are lower). These conditions can affect the performance of the ETF and create tracking errors.

Advantages of Bitcoin ETFs

Image Source: Ebonex

Bitcoin ETFs offer several distinct benefits:

• Ease of Access: Investors can buy shares through their regular brokerage accounts, avoiding the need to open cryptocurrency wallets or exchange accounts.

• Regulatory Oversight: ETFs are regulated by financial authorities, reducing risks associated with fraud or mismanagement.

• Diversification: Bitcoin ETFs allow investors to include cryptocurrency exposure in their portfolios alongside traditional assets such as stocks and bonds.

• Reduced Security Risks: Since investors do not need to manage private keys, they avoid the risks associated with losing access to digital wallets.

• Liquidity: Bitcoin ETFs can be bought and sold during market hours, providing liquidity and minimizing delays associated with crypto exchanges.

• Tax Efficiency: In certain jurisdictions, ETFs may offer more favorable tax treatment compared to directly holding Bitcoin.
  

Risks and Drawbacks of Bitcoin ETFs

While Bitcoin ETFs offer several advantages, they are not without risks:

• Management Fees: ETFs charge management fees, which can reduce returns, especially over the long term.

• Tracking Errors: Futures-based ETFs may not perfectly mirror Bitcoin’s spot price, leading to tracking discrepancies.

• Market Volatility: Bitcoin remains highly volatile, and ETF investors are exposed to this price volatility.

• Limited Control: Investors in Bitcoin ETFs do not own Bitcoin directly, meaning they miss out on activities such as staking or using Bitcoin in decentralized finance (DeFi).

• Roll Costs: Futures ETFs may incur roll costs when contracts are renewed, which can impact performance negatively over time.
  

Bitcoin ETFs vs. Holding Bitcoin Directly

Feature	Bitcoin ETF	Direct Bitcoin Ownership
Accessibility	Traded on stock exchanges	Requires setting up a crypto wallet
Security	Regulated custodians store Bitcoin	Self-managed storage (risk of lost keys)
Management Fees	Yes, typically 0.5%–1% annually	No management fees (only network fees)
Market Hours	ETF trades during stock exchange hours	Available 24/7 on crypto exchanges
Tax Treatment	Often more favorable for ETFs	Varies by jurisdiction

Global Overview of Bitcoin ETFs

United States

In January 2024, the Securities and Exchange Commission approved the listing and trading of Spot Bitcoin ETFs. Prior to that, the U.S. had approved Bitcoin futures-based ETFs (i.e., funds that invest in Bitcoin futures contracts) but not ETFs that hold Bitcoin itself.

Canada

Canada became the first country to approve a spot Bitcoin ETF in 2021. The Purpose Bitcoin ETF offers Canadian investors the ability to invest in Bitcoin directly through traditional brokerage accounts. This has made it easier for investors to access Bitcoin through tax-advantaged accounts, such as Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs).

Europe

Several European countries, including Germany and Switzerland, have approved Bitcoin products called exchange-traded products (ETPs). These products are listed on major European exchanges, providing regulated Bitcoin exposure to both retail and institutional investors.

Leading Bitcoin ETFs and Market Players

• Shares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT): The largest U.S. spot Bitcoin ETF by assets, issued by BlackRock.

• Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC): A leading spot Bitcoin ETF from Fidelity with significant inflows.

• Bitwise Bitcoin ETF (BITB): A low-fee spot Bitcoin ETF that has grown quickly since launch.

• ARK 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (ARKB): A spot Bitcoin ETF backed by ARK Invest and 21Shares, known for strong liquidity.

  VanEck Bitcoin Trust (HODL): A spot Bitcoin ETF from VanEck that offers direct Bitcoin exposure.
  

Conclusion

Bitcoin ETFs offer a streamlined way for investors to gain exposure to Bitcoin without the complexities of direct ownership. They provide the benefits of regulated markets, ease of access, and liquidity while mitigating some of the risks associated with managing Bitcoin directly. However, they also come with drawbacks, such as management fees and tracking errors, particularly for futures-based ETFs.